I've been reading some interesting articles recently on giving kids room to do their own thing. This one,
The Over Parenting Crisis, is well written. The author, Katie Allison Granju, is someone I used to be on a small parenting email list with waaaaaaay back when I first began exploring parenting in the mid 90's.
I like to read her articles and to see that her kids, all of whom were parented in an attachment style, including extended nursing, have grown into strong, independent individuals.
When Riley was a baby he was a big nurser and preferred to view the world from his cozy spot on my hip, nestled in the sling. Normal primate baby, basically. His bright brown eyes could be seen following conversations, and watching me write checks, make meals, weed the garden and all the other essential minutia of daily life. I can't count the times people would notice him following what was going on and would say 'He doesn't miss a thing, does he?'. Nope, he doesn't.
Now he's three he strikes up conversations of his own and wanders freely out of my view. He takes risks, figures things out, strides with his head up and exudes a happy confidence. I don't think it's a coincidence.
I was talking to a friend at the park yesterday whose daughter is not quite two. She said she wonders if her daughter will ever grow out of the need to be held quite so much or will ever go to out of town relatives when they reach for her. She said that it's been awkward on occasion because some of her family members believe that she's making her daughter clingy by her attachment parenting style. I told her that needing reassurance and balking at strangers sounds pretty normal for this age and that Riley was exactly the same way. She watched him balance along the low stone wall around the perimeter of the playground and walk to the far side of the park to pick up pine cones and we laughed at how 'clingy' my child is. We talked about the differences in how a two year old and three year old interact with the world and about how hard it is to remember what's actually normal for kids when our culture seems to make a point of drumming babyhood out of babies as soon as they emerge from the womb.
I don't believe that pushing a baby away will ever do anything but instill a sense of isolation, fear and mistrust. Can a baby find her way from there to independence? (and I mean real independence rather than bluff) I'm skeptical. Will she be strong inside? (and again, real strength, not posturing) I doubt it. Responsive, consistent care and an introduction to their world as a safe, interesting place makes strong, independent kids. How did we get so far away from that? All the animals in the world have it down pat, for crying out loud.
Our culture dictates that we need to get our babies away from us as soon as possible and then spend the remainder of the kids lives climbing all over them. It's just bizarre. Another good article is this one on
Over-Parenting and Social Disaster.